The stage count fixes the height; the vapour and liquid traffic fixes the diameter. A tray works only inside a window. Push too much vapour and it floods; too much liquid and the downcomers back up or choke; too little vapour and it weeps or dumps. Sizing means placing the design point and the turndown point inside that window with margin.
The limits of a tray
- Jet (entrainment) flood. Vapour carries so much liquid to the tray above that liquid accumulates and the column fills. The usual upper limit in low- to moderate-pressure columns.
- Downcomer backup flood. The liquid head needed to push liquid down the downcomer, against the tray pressure drop, rises until the froth in the downcomer reaches the tray above.
- Downcomer choke. The froth entering the downcomer is too fast to release its vapour. With high-pressure distillation and foaming systems this is the most common capacity limit 6.
- Weeping and dumping. The lower limit: not enough vapour pressure drop to hold liquid on the deck.
- Spray regime. At low liquid loads the deck liquid is blown into spray. Weir loads below about 2–3 US gpm per inch of weir (18–27 m³/h per metre) can produce it 6.
Flooding velocity: Souders–Brown and Fair
The flooding vapour velocity comes from a balance between the drag on a droplet and its weight, with the capacity factor CSB taken from Fair’s correlation as a function of the flow parameter and the tray spacing 3:
FLV = (L / V) √(ρV / ρL) (mass flows)(31)
un,f = CSB (σ / 20)0.2 FHA FSF √[(ρL − ρV) / ρV] (on the net area)(32)
CSB [m/s] = 0.0105 + 8.127 × 10⁻⁴ TS0.755 exp(−1.463 FLV0.842) (TS in mm)(33)
Equation (33) is Lygeros and Magoulas’s fit of Fair’s chart, as given in Perry’s Handbook; it departs from the chart by up to about 20 % in places, so treat it as a screening value 8. σ is the surface tension in mN/m. FHA = 1 when the hole area is 10 % of the active area or more, and 5(Ah/Aa) + 0.5 between 6 and 10 % 34. FSF is the system (foaming) factor, 1 for non-foaming systems.
Design at 80–85 % of flood for non-foaming systems 3,33. Kister’s rule-of-thumb flood C-factors are a useful cross-check: about 0.35–0.42 ft/s (0.11–0.13 m/s) for trays at 600–900 mm spacing and 0.25–0.35 ft/s (0.08–0.11 m/s) at 450–600 mm, for pressures below 7 bar 6.
Diameter
An = QV / (f un,f) Ac = An / (1 − Ad/Ac) D = √(4 Ac / π)(34)
QV is the vapour volumetric flow, f the design fraction of flood, Ad the downcomer area (typically 10–15 % of the column area for a single pass). The active (bubbling) area is Aa = Ac − 2Ad. For a segmental downcomer of 12 % of the area, the weir length is about 0.76 D.
Size the top and the bottom of each section, because densities and flows change down the column; the larger diameter usually governs the whole column, or the shell is swaged where the two differ a lot. Below about 0.76 m, trays need special cartridge construction and packing is often the better choice 12.
Tray pressure drop and downcomer backup
how = 750 [Lw / (ρL lw)]2/3 (mm liquid; Lw in kg/s, lw in m)(35)
hd = 51 (uh / C0)² ρV / ρL hr = 12.5 × 10³ / ρL ht = hd + (hw + how) + hr(36)
hdc = 166 [Lw / (ρL Am)]² hb = (hw + how) + ht + hdc ≤ ½ (TS + hw)(37)
After Sinnott 3. how is the crest over the weir, hd the dry-deck drop (uh the hole velocity, C0 ≈ 0.7–0.85 the orifice coefficient), hr the residual head, ht the total tray drop, hdc the head lost under the downcomer apron (Am the clearance area) and hb the clear-liquid backup. The ½ allows for a froth density of about 0.5 in the downcomer. Keep at least 3 s of liquid residence in the downcomer.
The backup is the sum of every resistance the liquid must overcome: the dry-deck drop, the weir and crest, the liquid gradient and the loss under the downcomer 17. That is why a high-pressure column with low-density vapour and a lot of liquid often runs out of downcomer before it runs out of deck. Try the debutaniser preset in Figure 7.
Weeping, choke and weir loading
Fh = uh √ρV ≥ 10 Pa0.5 (Prince, optimistic) … 14.6 Pa0.5 (Branan, conservative)(38)
Hole F-factor limits for a standard sieve tray, converted from 8.2 and 12 ft/s (lb/ft³)0.5 10. Another practical rule keeps the dry-deck drop above about 13 mm (0.5 in) of liquid at the lowest rate 10. Sinnott’s weep-point chart gives a liquid-height-dependent alternative 3.
Kister’s rule-of-thumb choke limits 6.
| Downcomer entrance velocity at choke, below 7 bar | ft/s | m/s |
| Non-foaming organic and hydrocarbon systems | 0.45 | 0.137 |
| Foaming circulating systems with antifoam | 0.20–0.25 | 0.06–0.08 |
| Once-through foaming systems, or no antifoam | 0.15 | 0.046 |
Weir-loading guideline from the Nutter manual, as quoted by Summers 16. A flood correlation that already includes the weir load makes such limits redundant, but they are a quick screen.
| Tray spacing | mm | Add passes above, gpm/in of weir | m³/h per m of weir |
| 12 in | 305 | 3 | 27 |
| 15 in | 381 | 5 | 45 |
| 18 in | 457 | 8 | 72 |
| 21 in | 533 | 10 | 89 |
| 24 in | 610 | 13 | 116 |
Column height
H = (Nactual − 1) × TS + Htop + Hbottom + extra space at feeds, draws and manways(39)
Allow about 1–1.5 m above the top tray for vapour disengagement and the reflux inlet, and 2–3 m below the bottom tray for the sump hold-up and the reboiler return 33. Feed trays and manway trays usually get extra spacing. The skirt adds the height needed for pump NPSH and for a thermosiphon reboiler’s static head.
Packed columns
Packed-column capacity comes from the generalised pressure-drop correlation (GPDC): Strigle’s chart for random packings and Kister and Gill’s for structured packings. Its ordinate is the capacity parameter CP = Cs Fp0.5 ν0.05 (US units) and its abscissa the flow parameter. Kister and Gill’s equation locates flood by its pressure drop 18:
ΔPflood = 0.12 Fp0.7 (in. H₂O per ft of packing, Fp in ft⁻¹)(40)
Design at 70–80 % of flood, and remember that efficiency falls off before hydraulic flood: vendors quote a “maximum efficient capacity” below the flood point. Koch-Glitsch, for example, routinely designs to 90 % of maximum efficient capacity 15.